Public comment sentiment on educational videos: Understanding the effects of presenter gender, video format, threading, and moderation on YouTube TED talk comments
Dousay, Tonia A.
Lowenthal, Patrick R.
MetadataShow full item record
Scholars, educators, and students are increasingly encouraged to participate in online spaces. While the current literature highlights the potential positive outcomes of such participation, little research exists on the sentiment that these individuals may face online and on the factors that may lead some people to face different types of sentiment than others. To investigate these issues, we examined the strength of positive and negative sentiment expressed in response to TEDx and TED-Ed talks posted on YouTube (n = 655), the effect of several variables on comment and reply sentiment (n = 774,939), and the projected effects that sentiment-based moderation would have had on posted content. We found that most comments and replies were neutral in nature and some topics were more likely than others to elicit positive or negative sentiment. Videos of male presenters showed greater neutrality, while videos of female presenters saw significantly greater positive and negative polarity in replies. Animations neutralized both the negativity and positivity of replies at a very high rate. Gender and video format influenced the sentiment of replies and not just the initial comments that were directed toward the video. Finally, we found that using sentiment as a way to moderate offensive content would have a significant effect on non-offensive content. These findings have far-reaching implications for social media platforms and for those who encourage or prepare students and scholars to participate online.
DescriptionThe definitive version of record of this article is available at https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0197331.
The following license files are associated with this item:
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Gendered discussion of politicians in news : how can we prepare future female politicians for media gender bias? Lawrie, Hannah J. (2015-09-24)This research adds to the pre-existing knowledge of gender bias towards women in media. Through a focused review of political news media in British Columbia, this research found little evidence of gender bias towards women ...
Canal, John P.; Hanlan, Lee; Key, Jessie; Lavieri, Sophie; Paskevicius, Michael; Sharma, Dev (American Chemical Society, 2016-11-22)The effectiveness of instructional videos as a teaching tool in the chemistry laboratory curricula at both Simon Fraser University (SFU) and Vancouver Island University (VIU) is examined. Five categories of videos used in ...
Video methods beyond representation: Experimenting with multimodal, sensuous, affective intensities in the 21st century Vannini, Phillip (Routledge, 2014)I received Charlotte Bates’s kind request to write the conclusion to this fine and timely collection of essays as Jonathan Taggart and I were en route back home after a week spent filming and doing fieldwork on the East ...